2009–2012[]
2012–2013[]
This version has the logo mainly clean, instead of it's rough-looking. The logo was used in 2012 for promotional materials, when they used it in the 2013 event.
2014[]
2015–2019[]
2020–present[]
On July 5, 2020, the PPV was named "The Horror Show at Extreme Rules" (originally Extreme Rules: The Horror Show). By 2021, it reverts back to "Extreme Rules".